District Court, W.D. Wisconsin March 24, 2020, 3:17-cv-00401 (More, Caroline v. Carey)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-03-2020

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN

CAROLINE PAULA MORE,

Plaintiff,

OPINION and ORDER

v.

17-cv-401-jdp

DAN CAREY and DANIEL GUENTZ,

Defendants.1

Plaintiff Caroline Paula More was arrested by defendants Sergeant Dan Carey and

Deputy Daniel Guentz of the Iowa County Sheriff’s Department. More brings Fourth

Amendment claims against Carey and Guentz based on her allegation that she had been

handcuffed to a bed for three hours by sheriff’s department staff. Dkt. 8. Defendants move for

summary judgment. Dkt. 24. Even if jurors were to believe More’s account, they could not

reasonably conclude that defendants violated More’s rights. Guentz acted reasonably in

restraining More and Carey was not involved in handcuffing her at all. I will grant defendants’

motion for summary judgment and dismiss this case.

More also asks me to reprimand and sanction defendants’ attorney. Dkt. 45. She says

that he intentionally delayed mailing her a copy of defendants’ reply brief. But More has not

shown that the delay was intentional or that she was prejudiced in any way by the delay, so I

will deny her request.

1 The court has updated the caption to reflect defendants’ names as stated in their motion for

summary judgment, Dkt. 25.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

More did not respond to defendants’ proposed facts or submit her own proposed facts

as required by this court. Instead, she includes unsworn factual allegations in her brief. Because

More is proceeding pro se, I will consider those allegations as if she had submitted them in a

sworn affidavit or declaration. In setting out the facts, I credit More’s version of any disputed

fact.

On the morning of May 24, 2014, Guentz pulled More over for speeding. More was

confrontational and profane with Guentz, so he quickly radioed for backup. She told him that

she had mental health problems, and she said several times that she wanted to kill herself. She

said that she would use her car to do so.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.