Superior Court of Guam December 10, 2020, CF0387-20 (People v. Dungca)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-12-2020

combined-opinion

FQLEQ

SUFERIOR CDURT

'32.. au-AH

ZUZUDEC 10 PH 1.~55=

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF GuAnLERH or t:0uRT

Bye

PEOPLE OF GUAM, Criminal Case No. CF0387-20

GPD Report No. 20-17543

Plaintiff,

vs.

DECISION AND ORDER

GRANTING DEFENDANT'S

DUANE ARTHUR DUNGCA, MOTION IN LIMINE

DOB: 09/01/1980

Defendant.

INTRODUCTION

This matter came before the Honorable Dana A. Gutierrez on October 23, 2020 for a

hearing O11 Defendant Duane Arthur Dungca's Motion in Liming. Present via Zoom was

Attorney David Highsmith of the Public Defender Service Corporation representing Defendant

Duane Arthur Dungca ("Defendant") and Assistant Attorney General Leonardo Rapadas

representing the People of Guam. The Motion was unopposed by the People. The Court now

issues this Decision and Order GRANTING Defendant's Motion in Lixnine.

BACKGROUND

Defendant is charged with two (2) counts of First Degree Criminal Sexual Conduct (As a

First Degree Felony) and three (3) counts of Second Degree Criminal Sexual Conduct (As a First

Degree Felony). On September 29, 2020, Defendant filed the instant Motion in order to

"exclude all hearsay testimony from other witnesses regarding the victim's account of the

incidents alleged in the indictment and certain related expert testimony." Mot. in Limine, at 1

DECISION AND ORDERGRANTINGDEFENDANT'S MOTIONIN LHVIINE

CF0387-20, People v. DuaneArldmurDungca

(Sept. 29, 2020). In sum, Defendant requests the following be excluded at a trial on this matter:

1) hearsay testimony regarding statements made orally or in writing by the victim to the victim's

mother, relatives, or to the police "unless they are admissible according to the mle against

hearsay and Supreme Court of Guam precedent," and 2) expert opinion testimony used for the

purpose of bolstering the victim's credibility. Id. at 1, 3-4.

The People did not file a written opposition to the Motion, and at the October 23, 2020

hearing, the People did not raise any arguments in opposition to the Motion.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.