Court of Appeals of Washington February 25, 2020, 52641-7 (In Re Detention Of V.S.)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-02-2020

Filed

Washington State

Court of Appeals

Division Two

February 25, 2020

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

DIVISION II

In the Matter of the No. 52641-7-II

Detention of

V.S.,

Appellant.

UNPUBLISHED OPINION

CRUSER, J. — V.S. appeals the order committing her to involuntary treatment for 180

days, arguing that the State did not present sufficient evidence to support the commissioner’s

findings of fact and conclusions of law. Specifically, V.S. argues that the State was required to

produce evidence sufficient to prove both that she presented a likelihood of serious harm and that

she continued to be gravely disabled to extend her involuntary treatment. The State’s failure to

demonstrate that she presented a likelihood of serious harm by evidence of actual threats, V.S.

argues, renders the evidence supporting the conclusion that she was gravely disabled insufficient.

The State responds that there was substantial evidence sufficient to support the commissioner’s

findings and conclusion that V.S. continued to be gravely disabled and that it was not required to

also prove that V.S. presented a likelihood of serious harm.

No. 52641-7-II

We agree with the State and hold that the State was not required to produce evidence

sufficient to show that V.S. posed a likelihood of serious harm because V.S.’s involuntary

treatment was not extended under that commitment standard. The trial court’s finding that V.S.

continued to be gravely disabled as a result of her mental health condition was a sufficient basis

under RCW 71.05.320(4)(d) to extend V.S.’s involuntary treatment. The State produced

substantial evidence sufficient to support this finding. We affirm the order of involuntary

treatment.

FACTS

V.S. was initially admitted to Western State Hospital in June 2017. Prior to her placement

at Western State, V.S. resided in an adult family home. Due to deterioration in her mental health,

V.S. was taken to St. Clare Hospital and placed on emergency 72-hour detention.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.