Court of Appeals of Washington March 30, 2020, 79160-5 (State Of Washington v. Jonathan Dennington)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-2020

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

DIVISION ONE

Respondent,

No. 79160-5-I (consol. with No.

v. 79161-3-I and No. 79162-1-I)

JONATHAN LAWRENCE DENNINGTON, PUBLISHED OPINION

Appellant.

DWYER, J. — Jonathan Dennington appeals from an order holding him in

contempt of court and sanctioning him to 30 days of confinement. Because the

trial court had the authority to hold Dennington in contempt, but did not provide

Dennington his statutorily required opportunity to speak in mitigation of his

contempt, we affirm the finding of contempt, reverse the sanction imposed, and

remand for imposition of the appropriate contempt sanction after Dennington is

given the opportunity to speak in mitigation.

I

The State charged Dennington with multiple offenses related to vehicle

theft. To ensure sufficient time to conduct witness interviews, defense counsel

filed a motion to continue Dennington’s trial date, which the court granted over

Dennington’s personal objection.

Following the ruling, the prosecutor and the court briefly discussed

proposed amendments to the information. Because the court’s calendar had 108

No. 79160-5-I/2

cases and the courtroom was full of people awaiting their hearings, the trial judge

asked the prosecutor to wait until another time to seek amendments. The

prosecutor agreed.

At the close of this discussion, Dennington made a reference to the

prosecutor’s personal appearance, stating that “she needs to lose weight

somehow.” This comment prompted the following exchange:

The Court: Let’s go. Sir, you need to watch your conduct in my

courtroom. Come back here, Mr. Dennington.[1]

[Dennington]: I don’t respect you. I don’t respect the court.

The Court: I got it—

[Dennington]: I don’t respect the liars that you entertain in your

court.

The Court: But your conduct in my courtroom is important.

[Dennington]: Do something about it. I don’t care about that.[2]

The Court: All right, I’m going to find you in contempt of court, sir.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.