Texas Court of Appeals, 4th District (San Antonio) April 1, 2020, 04-18-00131-CV (Lorraine Kenyon, Individually and as of the Estate of Theodore Kenyon v. Elephant Insurance Company, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-04-2020

Fourth Court of Appeals

San Antonio, Texas

DISSENTING OPINION

No. 04-18-00131-CV

Lorraine KENYON, Individually and as Executrix of the Estate of Theodore Kenyon,

Appellant

v.

ELEPHANT INSURANCE COMPANY, LLC,

Appellee

From the 224th Judicial District Court, Bexar County, Texas

Trial Court No. 2016CI14055

Honorable Michael E. Mery, Judge Presiding

DISSENT TO OPINION ON EN BANC RECONSIDERATION

Opinion by: Luz Elena D. Chapa, Justice

Dissenting Opinion by: Sandee Bryan Marion, Chief Justice

Dissenting Opinion by: Rebeca C. Martinez, Justice

Sitting en banc: Sandee Bryan Marion, Chief Justice

Rebeca C. Martinez, Justice

Patricia O. Alvarez, Justice

Luz Elena D. Chapa, Justice

Irene Rios, Justice

Beth Watkins, Justice

Liza A. Rodriguez, Justice

Delivered and Filed: April 1, 2020

The majority imposes a new duty upon an auto insurer that answers an insured’s telephone

call. This new duty requires an insurer to “exercise reasonable care in providing [post-accident]

guidance so as not to increase the risk” of physical harm to the insured, including ascertaining

whether the insured is physically safe before answering her questions or permitting or encouraging

Dissenting Opinion 04-18-00131-CV

her to document damage to her vehicle. Because I would hold no such duty exists in Texas, I

respectfully dissent.

Background

After she was involved in a single-vehicle accident in San Antonio, appellant Lorraine

Kenyon (“Kenyon”) called her auto insurer, appellee Elephant Insurance Company, LLC

(“Elephant”), from her vehicle on the side of the road. Speaking to Elephant’s first notice of loss

(“FNOL”) representative located in a Virginia call center, Kenyon reported she had no injuries but

her vehicle sustained damage. The call transcript reflects Kenyon asked the FNOL representative:

“Do you want us to take pictures?” The FNOL representative answered: “Yes, ma’am. Go ahead

and take pictures.” Kenyon’s husband Theodore arrived on the scene, and Kenyon told him:

“[T]hey need pictures.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.