Court of Appeals of Washington April 7, 2020, 52687-5 (Lester And Susan Riley v. David And Susan Valaer)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-04-2020

Filed

Washington State

Court of Appeals

Division Two

April 7, 2020

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

DIVISION II

LESTER RILEY and SUSAN K. RILEY,

husband and wife,

No. 52687-5-II

Appellants,

v.

DAVID VALAER and SUSAN E. VALAER, UNPUBLISHED OPINION

husband and wife,

Defendants,

and

BLAINE HUNTER and MELISSA HUNTER,

husband and wife; and BANK OF THE

PACIFIC,

Respondents.

GLASGOW, J.—Lester and Susan K. Riley owned two lots, one contained a home, an

attached garage, and a patio (east lot), while the other lot was vacant (west lot). Part of the attached

garage encroached on the otherwise vacant west lot. The encroachment has existed since before

the Rileys owned both lots.

Blaine and Melissa Hunter ultimately purchased the east lot, and they knew at the time that

their garage and patio encroached on the vacant west lot. The Rileys still owned the west lot.

The Rileys sued to force the Hunters to remove the encroachment. After a bench trial, the

trial court ruled that it would be inequitable to order ejectment under the “liability rule,” which

allows a court to decline to require removal of an encroachment if certain factors are met. The trial

No. 52687-5-II

court quieted title to the area containing the encroachment in favor of the Hunters and ordered the

Hunters to pay the Rileys for the strip of land.

The Rileys appeal, arguing that the Hunters cannot satisfy the elements of the liability rule

because they knew of the encroachment when they bought the house, and the trial court’s findings

of fact did not support its conclusion of law that it would be inequitable to force the Hunters to

remove the encroachment.

The Rileys do not dispute any of the trial court’s enumerated findings of fact, so we treat

them as verities on appeal, but some findings of fact embedded in the trial court’s conclusions of

law are disputed. These disputed findings are supported by substantial evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.