United States Tax Court May 12, 2020, 5444-13 (Oakbrook Land Holdings, LLC, William Duane Horton, Tax Matters Partner v. Commissioner)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-2020

154 T.C. No. 10

UNITED STATES TAX COURT

OAKBROOK LAND HOLDINGS, LLC, WILLIAM DUANE HORTON, TAX

MATTERS PARTNER, Petitioner v.

COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, Respondent

Docket No. 5444-13. Filed May 12, 2020.

In 2008 P donated a conservation easement to a qualified or-

ganization and claimed a charitable contribution deduction under

I.R.C. sec. 170(a). The easement deed provided that, if the conser-

vation restriction were extinguished at some future date, the donee

would receive a share of the proceeds equal to the fair market value

of the easement on the date the contribution was made. The deed

further provided that the donee’s share as thus determined would be

reduced by the value of any improvements made by the donor after

granting the easement. R disallowed the deduction, contending

(among other things) that the extinguishment clause violated the

requirements of sec. 1.170A-14(g)(6), Income Tax Regs.

In Oakbrook Land Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C.

Memo. 2020-54, issued concurrently with this Opinion, the Court

holds that the easement deed violates the “protected in perpetuity”

requirement of I.R.C. sec. 170(h)(5), as interpreted in sec.

1.170A-14(g)(6), Income Tax Regs., because the donee’s share of the

-2-

extinguishment proceeds (1) is based on a fixed historical value rather

than a proportionate share, and (2) is reduced by the value of any

improvements made by the donor. This Opinion addresses peti-

tioner’s challenge to the validity of the regulation.

Held: Sec. 1.170A-14(g)(6), Income Tax Regs., was properly

promulgated and is valid under the Administrative Procedure Act, 5

U.S.C. sec. 553 (2018).

Held, further, the construction of I.R.C. sec. 170(h)(5) as set

forth in sec. 1.170A-14(g)(6), Income Tax Regs., is valid under Chev-

ron, U.S.A., Inc. v. Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc., 467 U.S. 837 (1984).

David M. Wooldridge, Michelle A. Levin, Ronald A. Levitt, and Gregory P.

Rhodes, for petitioner.

W. Benjamin McClendon, Bruce K. Meneely, Robert W.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.