Supreme Court of Iowa May 15, 2020, 19-0369 (State of Iowa v. Chance Ryan Beres)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2020

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF IOWA

No. 19–0369

Filed May 15, 2020

STATE OF IOWA,

Appellee,

vs.

CHANCE RYAN BERES,

Appellant.

Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Poweshiek County, Joel D.

Yates, Judge.

A defendant seeks interlocutory review of the denial of his motion to

dismiss, arguing that an earlier plea agreement bars the State from

bringing the present charges. DISTRICT COURT ORDER REVERSED

AND CASE REMANDED.

Vidhya K. Reddy, Assistant Appellate Defender, for appellant.

Thomas J. Miller, Attorney General, Louis S. Sloven, Assistant

Attorney General, and Bart K. Klaver, County Attorney, for appellee.

2

MANSFIELD, Justice.

I. Introduction.

This case gives us the opportunity to reaffirm once more that plea

agreements are contracts, and accordingly, they are subject to general

principles of contract law.

The plea agreement here provided that the defendant would plead

guilty to his pending charge of second-degree arson, that he would

cooperate in an interview regarding some other suspicious fires that had

occurred, and that the State would not bring charges regarding those other

fires. After the defendant pled guilty, the State changed its mind and

decided it did not need or want the interview. It advised the defendant

before sentencing he would be charged with other arsons and gave him an

opportunity to withdraw from the plea agreement. The defendant declined

to withdraw. Nonetheless, the State brought four additional arson

charges. The defendant moved to dismiss them as a breach of the plea

agreement. The district court denied the motion, and we granted

interlocutory review.

Consistent with the law of contracts, we now hold that the State

could not unilaterally withdraw from the plea agreement either by

declining to conduct the interview or by making an offer of rescission that

the defendant did not accept.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.