New York Court of Appeals May 21, 2020, 56, 58 (Matter of Seawright v. Board of Elections / Matter of Hawatmeh v. State Board of Elections)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-2020

State of New York OPINION

Court of Appeals This opinion is uncorrected and subject to revision

before publication in the New York Reports.

No. 56

In the Matter of Rebecca Seawright,

Respondent,

v.

Board of Elections in the City of New York,

Appellant.

Louis Puliafito,

Intervenor-Appellant.

(And Other Related Proceedings.)

-----------------------------------------------

No. 58

In the Matter of Ola Hawatmeh,

Appellant,

v.

New York State Board of Elections,

Respondent,

James Goblet, et al.,

Respondents.

For No. 56:

Elina Druker, for appellant

Lawrence A. Mandelker, for intervenor-appellant

Gregory Soumas, for respondent

For No. 58:

John Ciampoli, for appellant

Joseph T. Burns, for respondents Goblet et al.

PER CURIAM:

In Matter of Seawright v Board of Elections in the City of New York, the Appellate

Division, First Department, held that – in light of the “unique circumstances” created by

the COVID-19 pandemic – the candidate’s belated filing of a cover sheet and certificate of

acceptance did not constitute a fatal defect (2020 NY Slip Op 02900, *1 [1st Dept May 14,

-1-

-2- Nos. 56 & 58

2020]). In Matter of Hawatmeh v New York State Board of Elections, the Appellate

Division, Third Department, rejected the First Department’s approach and reached the

opposite conclusion, holding that – notwithstanding the “unprecedented circumstances

created by the COVID-19 pandemic” – the candidate’s belated filing of a certificate of

acceptance was a fatal defect (2020 NY Slip Op 02907, *1-2 [3d Dept May 15, 2020]).1

We granted leave to resolve this departmental split. We now reverse in Seawright

and affirm in Hawatmeh.

I

Seawright

On March 19, 2020, incumbent New York State Assembly Member Rebecca

Seawright, a registered Democratic Party member, filed a petition designating her a

candidate for the office of Member of the Assembly for the 76th Assembly District on the

Democratic Party primary ballot.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.