Nevada Supreme Court May 28, 2020, 77085 (ROCK SPRINGS MESQUITE 2 OWNERS' ASS'N VS. RARIDAN)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-05-2020
combined-opinion
136 Nev., Advance Opinion 2.6
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
ROCK SPRINGS MESQUITE II No. 77085
OWNERS ASSOCIATION, A NEVADA
DOMESTIC NONPROFIT
CORPORATION,
Appellant, FILED
vs.
MAY 2 8 2020
STEPHEN J. RARIDAN AND JUDITH
ELIZABETH A. BROWN
A. RARIDAN, HUSBAND AND WIFE, CLERK F UPREME COUOT
Respondents. BY AA)
Y CLERK
Appeal from a district court order granting a motion to dismiss
in a declaratory relief action. Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County;
Timothy C. Williams, Judge.
Reversed and remanded.
Boyack Orme & Anthony and Edward D. Boyack, Las Vegas,
for Appellant.
Bingham Snow & Caldwell and Jedediah Bo Bingham and Clifford D.
Gravett, Mesquite,
for Respondents.
BEFORE GIBBONS, STIGLICH and SILVER, JJ.
OPINION
By the Court, STIGLICH, J.:
Claim preclusion prevents a party from suing based on a claim
that was or could have been brought in a prior lawsuit against the same
SUPREME COURT
OF
NEVADA
(0) I94TA 20 - 2-0021
party or its privies. In this appeal, appellant Rock Springs Mesquite II
Owners Association challenges a district court order granting respondents
Stephen and Judith Raridan's motion to dismiss on the basis of claim
preclusion. Rock Springs claimed in a prior lawsuit that its neighbor
wrongfully damaged its retaining wall (Case 1). Rock Springs seeks in this
lawsuit a judicial declaration that it can remove its retaining wall even
though doing so may cause the Raridans' adjacent masonry wall to collapse
(Case 2). Because Rock Springs did not raise a declaratory relief action in
Case 1 simply by proposing a jury instruction clarifying lateral support
obligations, we hold that Rock Springs' declaratory relief action in Case 2
was not brought in Case 1. Because Rock Springs' action in Case 2 is not
based on the same facts or alleged wrongful conduct as its claims in Case 1,
we conclude that Rock Springs' action in Case 2 could not have been brought
in Case 1.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit