Supreme Court of Pennsylvania June 10, 2020, 472 WAL 2019 (Commonwealth v. Brown, J.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-06-2020

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

WESTERN DISTRICT

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, : No. 472 WAL 2019

:

Respondent : Petition for Allowance of Appeal

: from the Unpublished

: Memorandum and Order of the

v. : Superior Court at No. 1468 WDA

: 2018 (Olson, Ott, Colins, JJ.),

: entered on October 2, 2019,

JAMIE M. BROWN, : affirming the PCRA Order of the

: Beaver County Court of Common

Petitioner : Pleas at No. CP-04-CR-0000913-

: 2001 (McBride, S.J.), entered on

: September 21, 2018

CONCURRING AND DISSENTING STATEMENT

JUSTICE WECHT

Although I agree that three of the four issues that Petitioner raises do not merit our

review, I would grant allocatur as to his remaining question. In that issue, Petitioner asks:

Whether, in a matter of first impression, the panel erred in finding that the

PCRA[1] court did not have jurisdiction to consider Brown’s timeliness claims

raised within sixty days of discovery following a remand for a hearing on a

separate timeliness claim, which is inconsistent with the plain language of

42 Pa.C.S. § 9545(b)(2), Commonwealth v. Lark, 746 A.2d 585 (Pa. 2000),

Commonwealth v. Porter, 35 A.3d 4 (Pa. 2012), and conflicts with

Commonwealth v. Montgomery, 181 A.3d 359 (Pa. Super. 2018) (en banc)?

Petition for Allowance of Appeal (“PAA”), 472 WAL 2019, at 7 (footnote omitted).

In Commonwealth v. Sepulveda, 144 A.3d 1270 (Pa. 2016), this Court stated “that

a PCRA court does not have discretion to treat new claims raised by a PCRA petitioner

1 Post Conviction Relief Act. 42 Pa.C.S. §§ 9541-46.

as an amended PCRA petition following remand from this Court unless such amendment

is expressly authorized in the remand order.” Id. at 1280 (emphasis added); see also

Commonwealth v. Rivera, 199 A.3d 365, 388-89 (Pa. 2018) (applying Sepulveda and

holding that a PCRA petitioner could not amend his petition upon remand).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.