Court of Chancery of Delaware June 11, 2020, C.A. No. 2017-0673-JRS (Manichaean Capital, LLC v. SourceHOV Holdings, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-2020

COURT OF CHANCERY

OF THE

STATE OF DELAWARE

417 S. State Street

JOSEPH R. SLIGHTS III Dover, Delaware 19901

VICE CHANCELLOR Telephone: (302) 739-4397

Facsimile: (302) 739-6179

Date Submitted: May 26, 2020

Date Decided: June 11, 2020

Rudolf Koch, Esquire T. Brad Davey, Esquire

Matthew W. Murphy, Esquire Matthew F. Davis, Esquire

Richards, Layton & Finger, P.A. Andrew H. Sauder, Esquire

One Rodney Square Caneel Radinson-Blasucci, Esquire

920 North King Street Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP

Wilmington, DE 19801 1313 North Market Street

Wilmington, DE 19801

Re: Manichaean Capital, LLC v. SourceHOV Holdings, Inc.

C.A. No. 2017-0673-JRS

Dear Counsel:

In this statutory appraisal proceeding, Respondent, SourceHOV Holdings,

Inc. (“SourceHOV” or the “Company”), has moved for a new trial under Court of

Chancery Rule 59(a) (the “Motion”)1 following the Court’s January 30, 2020, post-

1

See Resp’t’s Mot. for a New Trial (D.I. 117).

Manichaean Capital, LLC v. SourceHOV Holdings, Inc.

C.A. No. 2017-0673-JRS

June 11, 2020

Page 2

trial Memorandum Opinion (the “Opinion”).2 In the Opinion, I determined the fair

value of SourceHOV at the time of the Merger was $4,591 per share. 3 This

determination was based, in part, on my determination that SourceHOV’s

“fully ‘diluted’ share count” was 157,249 shares as of the applicable valuation date.4

One of the key disputes at trial was whether SourceHOV’s Restricted Stock

Units (“RSUs”) should be included in the share count.5 This question was important

because a higher share count would dilute the holdings of SourceHOV’s

stockholders, including Petitioners. 6 After deliberating the evidence, I found

Petitioners’ expert credibly testified that the RSUs should not be included in the

share count because, immediately before the Merger, it was entirely speculative

2

Manichaean Capital, LLC v. SourceHOV Hldgs., Inc., 2020 WL 496606, at *2 (Del. Ch.

Jan. 30, 2020); Ct. Ch. R. 59(a).

3

Manichaean Capital, 2020 WL 496606, at *1–2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.