Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit July 24, 2020, 18-3682 (Willashia Williams v. City of York)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-07-2020

PRECEDENTIAL

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT

No. 18-3682

WILLASHIA WILLIAMS

v.

CITY OF YORK, PENNSYLVANIA; VINCENT MONTE;

TERRY SEITZ; NICHOLAS FIGGE

Vincent Monte; Terry Seitz; Nicholas Figge,

Appellants

On Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Middle District of Pennsylvania

(D.C. No. 1-15-cv-00493)

District Judge: Honorable Sylvia H. Rambo

Argued on October 29, 2019

Before: HARDIMAN, PHIPPS, and NYGAARD, Circuit

Judges.

(Filed July 24, 2020)

Frank J. Lavery Jr. [Argued]

Stephen B. Edwards

Lavery Law

225 Market Street

Suite 304, P.O. Box 1245

Harrisburg, PA 17108

Donald B. Hoyt

City of York

101 South George Street

York, PA 17401

Attorneys for Appellants Vincent Monte and

Nicholas Figge

Sean P. McDonough

Dougherty Leventhal & Price

75 Glenmaura National Boulevard

Moosic, PA 18507

Attorney for Appellant Nicholas Terry Seitz

Frank J. Lavery Jr. [Argued]

Stephen B. Edwards

Lavery Law

225 Market Street

Suite 304, P.O. Box 1245

Harrisburg, PA 17108

Attorney for City of York

2

Lisa W. Basial*

[Argued]

Niles Benn

James F. Logue

Benn Law Firm

103 East Market Street

P.O. Box 5185

York, PA 17405

Attorney for Appellee Willashia Williams

OPINION OF THE COURT

HARDIMAN, Circuit Judge.

When a district court denies a public official qualified

immunity at summary judgment and the official appeals, the

scope of our review is limited. We can review “whether the set

of facts identified by the district court is sufficient to establish

a violation of a clearly established constitutional right.”

Ziccardi v. City of Philadelphia, 288 F.3d 57, 61 (3d Cir.

2002). But generally, “we lack jurisdiction to consider whether

the district court correctly identified the set of facts that the

summary judgment record is sufficient to prove.” Id. In

recognition of that limited jurisdiction, we have announced two

supervisory rules that facilitate our review and enhance the

reliability of district courts’ decisionmaking. First, in Forbes v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.