Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit July 31, 2020, 19-1736 (Randall Overton v. Matt MaCauley)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-07-2020

NOT RECOMMENDED FOR PUBLICATION

File Name: 20a0445n.06

Case No. 19-1736

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

FILED

Jul 31, 2020

RANDALL SCOTT OVERTON, ) DEBORAH S. HUNT, Clerk

)

Petitioner-Appellant, )

) ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED

v. ) STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR

) THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF

MATT MACAULEY, Warden, ) MICHIGAN

)

Respondent-Appellee. ) OPINION

)

)

BEFORE: DONALD, THAPAR, and NALBANDIAN, Circuit Judges.

NALBANDIAN, Circuit Judge. States have broad authority to craft, enact, and interpret

their criminal statutes. Although the federal judiciary often acts as a backstop, federalism cautions

us against wielding the federal constitution to meddle in state affairs. That said, the Fourteenth

Amendment’s Due Process Clause requires us to invalidate state court interpretations of criminal

statutes so unexpected and indefensible as to penalize behavior previously considered innocent.

See Bouie v. City of Columbia, 378 U.S. 347, 354 (1964). But this does not mean that every close

state-level criminal case warrants federal intervention. Instead, this Court recognizes fair-notice

due process violations only when the defendant could not have known that the state criminal statute

encompassed his conduct. Liberally permitting fair-notice due process claims to vacate state court

decisions would upset the foundational principal that federal judges exercise “neither Force nor

No. 19-1736 Overton v. MaCauley

Will, but merely judgment.” THE FEDERALIST NO. 78, at 523 (Alexander Hamilton) (J. Cooke ed.,

1961).

Overton tells us that his conduct could not have fallen under Michigan’s statutory definition

of sexual penetration. Because that statute requires an insertion into “the genital or anal openings

of another person’s body,” Mich. Comp. Laws Ann. § 750.520a(r) (emphasis added), he argues

that coercing or instructing a minor to self-penetrate does not amount to sexual penetration.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.