Ohio Court of Appeals August 12, 2020, C-190539 (Kassem v. Barnes)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-08-2020

[Cite as Kassem v. Barnes, 2020-Ohio-4046.]

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT OF OHIO

HAMILTON COUNTY, OHIO

NASSER KASSEM, : APPEAL NO. C-190539

TRIAL NO. 16CV-25130

Plaintiff-Appellee, :

O P I N I O N.

vs. :

RONALD BARNES, :

Defendant-Appellant. :

Civil Appeal From: Hamilton County Municipal Court

Judgment Appealed From Is: Reversed and Cause Remanded

Date of Judgment Entry on Appeal: August 12, 2020

Stuart L. Richards, for Plaintiff-Appellee,

Albert T. Brown, Jr., for Defendant-Appellant.

OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS

MOCK, Presiding Judge.

{¶1} Defendant-appellant Ronald Barnes, the tenant, appeals the trial

court’s judgment, following a jury trial, in favor of plaintiff-appellee Nasser Kassem,

the landlord, on his action for forcible entry and detainer, restitution of the premises

and unpaid rent. Because the trial court erroneously prohibited Barnes from

presenting the defense of retaliation to the eviction proceeding, we reverse the trial

court’s judgment and remand this matter for further proceedings.

I.

{¶2} Kassem filed a complaint for eviction and unpaid rent on November

14, 2016. Two weeks later, Barnes filed an answer generally denying the allegations

of the complaint and asserting three counterclaims. Barnes did not plead specific

supporting facts under these counterclaims nor did he request a specific amount of

monetary damages in the prayer for relief. The first two counterclaims simply

alleged that Kassem filed the eviction action in retaliation against Barnes. The third

counterclaim only alleged that the tenant was owed “damages and attorney fees.”

{¶3} Prior to trial, Kassem moved to dismiss Barnes’s counterclaims, which

the trial court granted. On the first day of trial, Barnes made an oral motion for leave

to amend his counterclaims, which the court denied. During the trial, Kassem

objected to Barnes’s attempt to introduce evidence of retaliation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.