Indiana Court of Appeals September 29, 2020, 20A-PL-395 (Terri Symons, John Nauyokas, Jennifer Reynolds, and David Dennison v. Gary Fish and Jeremey Fish)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-09-2020

ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLANTS ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEES

Jonathan D. Mattingly Bryan S. Redding

Sean P. Burke Caitlin R. Jared

Hamish S. Cohen Redding Law, LLC FILED

Jeffery Furminger Carmel, Indiana Sep 29 2020, 9:45 am

Mattingly Burke Cohen & Biederman

LLP CLERK

Indiana Supreme Court

Court of Appeals

Indianapolis, Indiana and Tax Court

IN THE

COURT OF APPEALS OF INDIANA

Terri Symons, John Nauyokas, September 29, 2020

Jennifer Reynolds, and David Court of Appeals Case No.

Dennison, 20A-PL-395

Appellants-Defendants/Counterclaim Appeal from the Hamilton

Plaintiffs, Superior Court

The Honorable Michael A. Casati,

v. Judge

The Honorable Steven R. Nation,

Gary Fish and Jeremey Fish, Judge

Appellees-Plaintiffs/Counterclaim Trial Court Cause No.

Defendants. 29D01-1508-PL-6964

Najam, Judge.

Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 20A-PL-395 | September 29, 2020 Page 1 of 20

Statement of the Case

[1] Terri Symons appeals the trial court’s judgment for Gary Fish and Jeremey Fish

(“the Sellers”) following a jury trial on the Sellers’ complaint for breach of

contract arising from the sale of a business. Symons presents seven issues for

our review, which we restate as the following four issues:

1. Whether a contract clause providing for treble damages is

an unenforceable penalty.

2. Whether the Sellers’ complaint is time barred by an

eighteen-month contractual limitations period.

3. Whether the evidence or the parties’ indemnification

clause supports an award of damages greater than

$250,000.

4. Whether Symons has met her burden on appeal to show

that the trial court abused its discretion in the award of

attorneys’ fees and costs to the Sellers.

[2] We affirm in part, reverse in part, and remand with instructions.

Facts and Procedural History

[3] On June 3, 2011, Symons, John Nauyokas, Jennifer Reynolds, and David

Dennison (collectively, “the Buyers”)1 purchased Breath of Life Home Medical

Equipment and Respiratory Services, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.