Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit November 12, 2020, 20-5032 (Mendy Barnett v. Dep't of Children's Services)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-11-2020

NOT RECOMMENDED FOR PUBLICATION

File Name: 20a0643n.06

Case Nos. 20-5010/5032

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

FILED

Nov 12, 2020

MENDY BARNETT, individually and as next )

DEBORAH S. HUNT, Clerk

friend of M.G.W. and M.W., )

)

Plaintiff-Appellant/Cross-Appellee, ) ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED

) STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR

v. ) THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF

) TENNESSEE

DANIEL SMITHWICK, )

)

Defendant-Appellee/Cross-Appellant. )

BEFORE: SUTTON, THAPAR, and READLER, Circuit Judges.

CHAD A. READLER, Circuit Judge. As often happens, we have before us competing

interests: the duty of public officials to act reasonably to protect children from harm, and the

fundamental rights of parents to raise their children without government interference. Because the

district court proceedings properly calibrated those considerations, we affirm the various

judgments entered in favor of the state officer.

BACKGROUND

Mendy Barnett and Marc Winters had a long and troubled history with the Tennessee

Department of Children’s Services (DCS). Over a seven-year span, DCS investigated the couple

nine times regarding allegations of neglect, lack of supervision, and drug exposure relating to their

two children, daughter M.G.W. and son M.W. That pattern continued when DCS received a report

Case Nos. 20-5010/5032, Barnett v. Smithwick

from a concerned babysitter that the children appeared hungry and dirty. DCS promptly dispatched

social workers to examine the children.

DCS’s efforts, however, were not well-received. Barnett and Winters refused every

attempt by DCS social workers to see the children. Failing on those fronts, DCS enlisted the help

of Daniel Smithwick, DCS’s lead regional attorney. Through Smithwick, DCS obtained an ex

parte order from the juvenile court granting the social workers enhanced investigatory powers.

The order required the parents to “allow entrance to the home, school, or place where the children

are located” for examination of the children.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.