Supreme Court of Pennsylvania November 17, 2020, 30 EAP 2020 (In Re: Canvassing Observ., Apl. of: Bd. of Elec.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-2020

[J-116-2020][M.O. - Todd, J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

EASTERN DISTRICT

IN RE: CANVASSING OBSERVATION : No. 30 EAP 2020

:

APPEAL OF: CITY OF PHILADELPHIA : Appeal from the November 5, 2020,

BOARD OF ELECTIONS : Single-Judge Order of the Honorable

: Christine Fizzano Cannon of the

: Commonwealth Court at No. 1094 CD

: 2020, reversing the November 3, 2020

: Order of the Honorable Stella Tsai of

: the Court of Common Pleas of

: Philadelphia County at November Term

: 2020, No. 07003

:

: SUBMITTED: November 13, 2020

DISSENTING OPINION

CHIEF JUSTICE SAYLOR DECIDED: November 17, 2020

The Commonwealth Court reasonably directed election officials in Philadelphia to

move restrictive barriers in the Convention Center closer to the ballot-canvassing

operations, which had been staged up to thirty-five yards from the areas to which the

statutorily-authorized candidate representatives were confined. Under the

Commonwealth Court’s order, these representatives could then observe whether ballots

were being counted lawfully to the best of their ability, consistent with health and safety

restrictions. The record -- as well as publicly-available video recordings from the

Convention Center -- amply demonstrate that this simply wasn’t the case previously.

The canvassing has now proceeded to near conclusion under an ensuing

agreement among the parties associated with federal litigation. In my judgment, the

matter is therefore moot -- or at least moot enough -- so that this Court’s discretionary

intervention was and is not required. Moreover, the Legislature already is signaling that

there will be an intense after-action review of the no-excuse mail-in voting regime, which

is in its infancy in Pennsylvania. Accordingly, I doubt that the Court’s present ruling,

relative to governance that is quite likely to be substantially refined, will be of any

importance in the future.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.