New York Court of Appeals November 24, 2020, 77 (Jin Ming Chen v. Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-11-2020

State of New York OPINION

Court of Appeals This opinion is uncorrected and subject to revision

before publication in the New York Reports.

No. 77

Jin Ming Chen,

Appellant,

v.

Insurance Company of the State of

Pennsylvania,

Respondent.

Kenneth J. Gorman, for appellant.

Elizabeth F. Ahlstrand, for respondent.

DiFIORE, Chief Judge:

This appeal involves a dispute concerning an excess insurer’s obligation to pay

interest on an underlying personal injury judgment after the primary policy was voided.

Like the courts below, we are unpersuaded by the injured plaintiff’s argument that the

excess policy provided overlapping coverage for certain interest payments covered in the

primary policy, and we therefore affirm the Appellate Division order.

-1-

-2- No. 77

Plaintiff Jin Ming Chen was injured at a construction site and sued the general

contractor Kam Cheung Construction, Inc. (Kam Cheung). At the time, Kam Cheung

maintained both primary and excess liability insurance policies: a primary policy with a

liability limit of $1 million per occurrence from Arch Specialty Insurance Company

(Arch) and an excess policy with $4 million per occurrence in coverage from defendant

Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania (ICSOP). In December 2011, Supreme

Court granted partial summary judgment to plaintiff in that action, and, in October 2013,

the court entered a personal injury judgment awarding plaintiff $2,330,000 plus

$396,933.70 in prejudgment interest. During that time, Arch commenced a declaratory

judgment action seeking rescission of the primary policy due to material

misrepresentations made by Kam Cheung in its application, securing a judgment

declaring that the Arch Policy was void ab initio. Thus, Arch provided no coverage

relating to the personal injury judgment.

Plaintiff subsequently commenced this action against ICSOP, the excess insurer,

asserting ICSOP was obligated to pay the entire underlying damages award.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.