Supreme Court of Virginia November 25, 2020, 191089 (Sheehy v. Williams)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-11-2020

PRESENT: All the Justices

KERRY ANN SHEEHY

OPINION BY

v. Record Nos. 190802 & 191089 JUSTICE D. ARTHUR KELSEY

NOVEMBER 25, 2020

RENEE WILLIAMS

FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE CITY OF VIRGINIA BEACH

James Clayton Lewis, Judge

The trial court in this case entered a civil judgment against Kerry Ann Sheehy based upon

a finding that she had violated Code § 8.01-40.4 by disseminating images of Renee Williams in a

manner prohibited by Code § 18.2-386.2. Sheehy filed two appeals arguing that the judgment

against her should be vacated. 1

While these appeals were pending, the judgment amount was paid in full. Seeking a

dismissal of both appeals, Williams contends that the voluntary-payment doctrine moots

Sheehy’s appeals of the now fully satisfied judgment. For the following reasons, we will retain

jurisdiction over this appeal and temporarily remand the case to the trial court for factual

findings on the voluntary-payment issue. Upon receiving the trial court’s findings, we will rule

upon Williams’s motion to dismiss.

I.

The trial court entered a final judgment against Sheehy on May 24, 2019, in the amount

of $50,845.18. Sheehy filed two notices of appeal, one before the entry of final judgment (April

23) and the other after the entry of final judgment (June 14). See supra note 1; infra note 9.

Based upon proffers made by Williams on appeal, it appears that she has never filed any petition

1

In Record No. 190802, Sheehy challenges the trial court’s liability and damages

findings, and in Record No. 191089, she seeks a vacatur of the court’s award of attorney fees and

costs to Williams. We consolidated both appeals and address them together in this opinion.

seeking execution of the judgment (such as a writ of fieri facias or garnishment, see Code

§§ 8.01-466, -511) or a petition in equity seeking the judicial sale of Sheehy’s real property, see

Code §§ 8.01-458, -462. See Mot. to Dismiss Appeal As Moot Ex. C, at 1-2 [hereinafter Mot. to

Dismiss].

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.