Court of Appeals of Washington December 1, 2020, 37159-0 (State of Washington v. T.P.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-12-2020

FILED

December 1, 2020

In the Office of the Clerk of Court

WA State Court of Appeals Division III

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

DIVISION THREE

STATE OF WASHINGTON, )

) No. 37159-0-III

Respondent, )

)

v. ) UNPUBLISHED OPINION

)

T.P., )

)

Appellant. )

FEARING, J. — T.P. appeals his conviction, in juvenile court, for rape. He claims

that the trial court admitted inadmissible and prejudicial testimony from the alleged

victim’s parents as to her reputation for truthfulness. We agree and reverse his

conviction. Because the juvenile court repeatedly admitted the inadmissible evidence,

because of the critical nature of the victim’s credibility, and because the court considered

all evidence when finding guilt, we decline to apply the presumption that the trial court,

in a bench trial, never considered inadmissible evidence when rendering a verdict.

FACTS

We glean the facts from testimony during a juvenile court bench trial.

T.P. and A.S., both 14 years old, attended the same junior high school. They never

interacted, however, until T.P. posted a “story” on Snapchat, a multimedia messaging

No. 37159-0-III

State v. T.P.

app. Report of Proceedings (RP) at 64. Snapchat permits the posting of messages,

stories, and pictures, which expire from the application after twenty-four hours. T.P.

inquired if anyone wanted to “kick it,” a chic term for relaxing with a friend. RP at 64.

A.S. responded affirmatively, and she and T.P. spent time together at a park near the

school later that day.

During their first encounter, T.P. repeatedly told A.S. that he wanted to have sex

and suggested that the two retire to the bushes. A.S. repetitively declined.

Over the next weeks, T.P. and A.S. continued to socialize. Eventually T.P. visited

A.S.’s home and became acquainted with A.S.’s parents. Neither T.P. nor A.S. know the

number of times T.P. visited A.S.’s home. When at A.S.’s home, the two fourteen-year-

olds played video games in A.S.’s bedroom.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.