Texas Court of Appeals, 8th District (El Paso) December 14, 2020, 08-18-00181-CV (Steve Juen and CSDT America, Inc. v. Noe Rodriguez)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-12-2020

COURT OF APPEALS

EIGHTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS

EL PASO, TEXAS

STEVE JUEN and CSDT § No. 08-18-00181-CV

AMERICA, INC.,

§ Appeal from the

Appellants,

§ County Court at Law No. 3

v.

§ of El Paso County, Texas

NOE RODRIGUEZ,

§ (TC# 2016DCV2973)

Appellee.

OPINION

Steve Juen (“Juen”) and CSDT America, Inc. (“CSDT”) (collectively, “Appellants”)

appeal from a final summary judgment in favor of Noe Rodriguez (“Rodriguez”) on his claims

against Juen and CSDT for fraud, and his claim against CSDT for breach of contract. We reverse

and remand.

BACKGROUND

CSDT contracted with Rodriguez for the purchase of Rodriguez’s single-family residence.

The purchase price was $759,000, to be paid in cash at closing. The contract did not provide for

financing of any portion of the contract price. The sale was scheduled to close on November 30,

2015, but that date was later extended to December 21, 2015. CSDT also obtained an unrestricted

right to terminate the contract on or before December 11, 2015. Even still, CSDT did not exercise

its option to terminate the contract and failed to close the sale on December 21, 2015. Juen, who

was the CEO and President of CSDT, later made two attempts to pay Rodriguez not in cash but by

means of purported instruments drawn on what Rodriguez contends are fictitious institutions.

Rodriguez ultimately filed suit against Juen and CSDT. Against both Juen and CSDT,

Rodriguez asserted claims for common law fraud (including fraudulent inducement) and statutory

fraud. And, as against only CSDT, Rodriguez asserted a claim for breach of contract. Responding,

Appellants filed a general denial, affirmative defenses, and asserted counterclaims for fraud and

breach of contract.

Rodriguez thereafter filed a traditional motion for summary judgment on each of his

claims. Appellants filed a response and an amended response, and Rodriguez filed objections and

amended objections to Appellants’ summary judgment evidence. No ruling on those objections

appears in the record.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.