New York Court of Appeals December 17, 2020, 91 (The People v. J.L.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-12-2020

State of New York OPINION

Court of Appeals This opinion is uncorrected and subject to revision

before publication in the New York Reports.

No. 91

The People &c.,

Respondent,

v.

J.L.,

Appellant.

Cynthia Colt, for appellant.

Dmitriy Povazhuk, for respondent.

RIVERA, J.:

The sole issue on this appeal is whether the trial court’s denial of defendant J.L.’s

request for a jury instruction on voluntary possession, in connection with a third-degree

-1-

-2- No. 91

criminal possession of a weapon count, constitutes reversible error. We conclude that the

evidence supported the jury charge and the error warrants a new trial on this count.

Defendant was tried on charges of criminal possession of a weapon and unlawful

possession of marihuana. Defendant was 17 years old when he was arrested and, if his

version of the underlying events is believed, although he was in the wrong place at the

wrong time, he was not in possession of a weapon. According to the prosecution, defendant

was criminally liable for constructive possession of a gun because he had dominion and

control over the bedroom where the gun was found. Defendant maintains that he did not

live in the apartment and was a temporary guest with no prior knowledge of the gun, and

that he discovered it unintentionally in the moments after he was shot, before leaving to

get assistance.

In the prosecutor’s case-in-chief, the two police officers who responded to an

emergency call testified that they found defendant sitting outside of a residential building,

bleeding from the back of his neck. Defendant told the officers that he had been shot while

he was in the kitchen of the building’s basement apartment. During a search of the

apartment, one of the officers followed a trail of blood into a back bedroom, where he saw

pools of blood on the floor, a bucket of plaster, garbage bags, a mattress with a foam topper

and blanket, and some dressers.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.