Texas Court of Appeals, 4th District (San Antonio) December 23, 2020, 04-19-00119-CV (Infinity County Mutual Insurance Company v. Michael Tatsch)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-12-2020

Fourth Court of Appeals

San Antonio, Texas

DISSENTING OPINION

No. 04-19-00119-CV

INFINITY COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,

Appellant

v.

Michael TATSCH,

Appellee

From the 216th Judicial District Court, Gillespie County, Texas

Trial Court No. 12977

Honorable N. Keith Williams, Judge Presiding

DISSENT TO OPINION ON EN BANC RECONSIDERATION

Opinion by: Luz Elena D. Chapa, Justice

Dissenting Opinion by: Patricia O. Alvarez, Justice (joined by Sandee Bryan Marion, Chief

Justice and Rebeca C. Martinez, Justice)

Sitting en banc: Sandee Bryan Marion, Chief Justice

Rebeca C. Martinez, Justice

Patricia O. Alvarez, Justice

Luz Elena D. Chapa, Justice

Irene Rios, Justice

Beth Watkins, Justice

Liza A. Rodriguez, Justice

Delivered and Filed: December 23, 2020

I agree with the majority that this case turns on a policy construction question, but because

the majority misconstrues the policy and fails to render the proper judgment, I respectfully dissent.

Dissenting Opinion 04-19-00119-CV

POLICY’S PLAIN LANGUAGE

Under “PART E—COVERAGE FOR DAMAGE TO YOUR INSURED AUTO,” the

“INSURING AGREEMENT” provision states as follows:

If you pay a specific premium for this coverage, we will pay for loss to your

insured auto, including its factory-installed, permanently attached equipment

which is considered standard for your insured auto, caused by:

1. Collision;

2. Comprehensive; or

3. Fire and Theft with Combined Additional Coverage . . . .

In Part E, loss is defined as “direct and accidental . . . damage to your insured auto.” The

definition reiterates that “insured auto” includes all the “equipment which is permanently installed

at the factory by the original make and model manufacturer and considered standard equipment

for such vehicle” but does not include, e.g., “[e]quipment or alterations installed by a conversion

facility to an auto or camper.” Thus, the policy covers “damage to your insured auto” but

excludes loss “[r]esulting from or caused by . . . [m]echanical . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.