Texas Court of Appeals, 11th District (Eastland) December 31, 2020, 11-18-00050-CV (Susan Davis Van Dyke v. the Navigator Group)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-2020

Opinion filed December 31, 2020

In The

Eleventh Court of Appeals

__________

No. 11-18-00050-CV

__________

SUSAN DAVIS VAN DYKE ET AL., Appellants

V.

THE NAVIGATOR GROUP ET AL., Appellees

On Appeal from the 118th District Court

Martin County, Texas

Trial Court Cause No. 6668

MEMORANDUM OPINION

The genesis of the dispute in this appeal is found in a double fraction “minerals

and mineral rights” reservation in a 1924 deed. In the 1924 deed, Geo. H. Mulkey

conveyed certain property to G.R. White and G.W. Tom. The deed contained the

following reservation:

It is understood and agreed that one-half of one-eighth of all minerals

and mineral rights in said land are reserved in grantors, Geo. H. Mulkey

and Frances E. Mulkey, and are not conveyed herein.

Appellants claim to derive ownership of one-half of the minerals and mineral

rights related to the property by virtue of that reservation. Appellants make that

claim as heirs and assigns, through the years, of the Mulkeys. We will refer to those

parties as “Appellants” or “the Mulkey Assignees.” 1

Contrary to Appellants’ claim, Appellees assert that Appellants only own one-

sixteenth of the minerals and mineral rights and that Appellees own the other fifteen-

sixteenths of the minerals and mineral rights as heirs and assigns, through the years,

of White and Tom. We will refer to those parties as “Appellees” or “the White

Assignees.”2

The parties filed various motions for summary judgment. By way of a

summary judgment order, the trial court agreed with the White Assignees and

1

Appellants are Susan Davis Van Dyke; Stephen L. Davis; Sheryl Ann Huttner f/k/a Ann Mulkey

Bell; Kay Elaine Keys; Jill Marie Stuckert, a/k/a Jill Marie Walker; George Dan Mulkey and Thomas J.

Mulkey, Trustees of the Mulkey Family Mineral Trust; Arthur B. Davis; Boyd Enterprises, Inc.; The

Huffington Foundation; Bishop-Windham Family Limited Partnership; Terry S. Key, Trustee of the Terry

S. Key Non-Exempt Trust; Roger A. Key, Trustee of the Roger A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.