District Court, N.D. Alabama August 7, 2020, 2:18-cv-01534 (Haman Inc v. Chubb Custom Insurance Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-08-2020

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ALABAMA

SOUTHERN DIVISION

HAMAN, INC., ]

]

Plaintiff, ]

]

v. ] CIVIL ACTION NO.

] 2:18-CV-01534-KOB

CHUBB CUSTOM INSURANCE ]

COMPANY, ]

]

Defendant. ]

MEMORANDUM OPINION

This case involving insurance coverage for an ill-fated Knight’s Inn motel

now comes before the court on Defendant Chubb Custom Insurance Company’s

motion to strike Plaintiff Haman, Inc.’s amended expert disclosures. (Doc. 69).

Chubb asserts that the court should not allow Haman’s amended disclosures

because Haman filed them after the deadline for expert disclosures and the later

filing prejudices Chubb.

Upon reviewing the submissions of the parties, the court finds most of

Haman’s amended disclosures justified or harmless, so the court will deny in part

Chubb’s motion to strike. However, the court will grant in part Chubb’s motion to

strike solely regarding Haman’s expert Tom Irmiter’s opinions on the

reasonableness of cost assessments, as Haman cannot show that the delayed

disclosure qualifies as justified or harmless because no basis exists for those

opinions in Haman’s prior expert disclosures or discovery.

I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

This case—which has a long history that includes a previous, dismissed-

without-prejudice complaint based on the same underlying events—arises from an

insurance dispute. Chubb issued to Haman a commercial property insurance

policy that covered certain damages to Haman’s Knight’s Inn motel. The

insurance policy contained an appraisal provision allowing each party, upon

demand of an appraisal relating to an insurance claim, to select its own

independent appraiser to assess the value of a loss on the property. If the

appointed independent appraisers could not agree on the value of the loss, then an

umpire selected by the appraisers would determine the value of the loss.

On March 22, 2014, a fire damaged Haman’s motel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.