District Court, W.D. Virginia September 27, 2021, 5:19-cv-00033 (Tilson v. Humphrey)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-09-2021

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

WESTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA

HARRISONBURG DIVISION

JARED TILSON, )

Plaintiff )

) Civil Action No. 5:19-cv-00033

v. )

) By: Michael F. Urbanski

ZOE HUMPHREY, et al., ) Chief United States District Judge

Defendants )

AMENDED MEMORANDUM OPINION!

This matter comes before the court on two motions for summary judgment filed by

the defendants. Defendant Shawn Smals bas filed a motion for summary judgment, ECF

No. 114, and defendants Stacy Stewart and Zoe Humphrey? have filed their own motion for

summary judgment, ECF No. 116. Plaintiff Jared Tilson has responded in opposition to

each of these motions. ECF Nos. 132, 133. Smals filed a reply brief in support of his motion

for summaty judgment, ECF No. 139, and Stewart and Humphrey filed reply briefs in

support of each of their motions, ECF Nos. 140 and 141. For the reasons explained herein,

the court will DENY in part and GRANT in part defendants Stewart and Humphtey’s

motion for summary judgment, ECF No. 116, and GRANT defendant Smals’ motion for

summary judgment, ECF No. 114.

1 The memorandum opinion is amended for the sole purpose of clarifying that the motion for

summary judgment, ECF No. 116, was granted in part and denied in part. No substantive changes have been

made to the memorandum opinion.

2 In bringing these motions, Stewart and Humphrey were originally joined by defendants Gary

Taylor, Debra Taylor, and Sonya Randall Edwards, but those defendants have since been dismissed upon

stipulation by the parties. ECF No. 137. The court also has dismissed the following defendants upon

stipulations by the parties: William Lee Hereford, Regina Chestnut, Donna Reynolds, and Barry Munsey, ECP

No. 78; as well as Bradford Barker, Chrystal Boyers, David Bauguess, Jr., James Doyle, and Douglas □□□□□□

ECF No. 83. The court also previously dismissed all claims against Middle River Regional Jail Authority

(“MJJRA”). See Order, ECF No. 66, at 2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.