Court of Appeals of Oregon April 27, 2022, A172244 (Monica v. Myers)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-2022

376

Submitted May 18, 2021, affirmed April 27, petition for review denied

September 1, 2022 (370 Or 212)

SUSAN MONICA,

Petitioner-Appellant,

v.

Paula MYERS,

Superintendent,

Coffee Creek Correctional Facility,

Defendant-Respondent.

Washington County Circuit Court

18CV07502; A172244

510 P3d 238

In this appeal from denial of post-conviction relief, petitioner claims she

received ineffective assistance of counsel during her criminal trial on two counts

of murder, among other charges. Specifically, she claims that trial counsel was

ineffective for failing to advance certain arguments related to a motion to sup-

press evidence discovered during the execution of a search warrant, failing to

impeach a state’s witness, failing to object to witness vouching, and failing to

rebut certain evidence related to an alleged murder weapon. The post-conviction

court denied her claims after concluding that the attorney performance was not

unreasonable and not prejudicial. Held: Trial counsel reasonably chose to focus

on whether a search warrant should have been issued at all, rather than whether

the search warrant was too broad, and because officers found a human leg in

plain view while searching the property, a different argument would have been

unlikely to affect the outcome of the trial. Trial counsel’s performance during the

trial was reasonable and, in any event, even if it was deficient, petitioner’s claims

were related to issues unlikely to affect the outcome of the trial. The trial court

did not err by concluding the trial counsel’s performance was reasonable and that

petitioner did not suffer prejudice as a result of attorney performance.

Affirmed.

Patricia A. Sullivan, Senior Judge.

Jedediah Peterson and O’Connor Weber, LLC, filed the

brief for appellant.

Ellen F. Rosenblum, Attorney General, Benjamin Gutman,

Solicitor General, and Rolf C. Moan, Assistant Attorney

General, filed the brief for respondent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.