Texas Court of Appeals, 14th District (Houston) July 14, 2022, 14-21-00409-CV (in the Interest of N.H., a Child)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-07-2022

Reversed and Rendered and Opinion filed July 14, 2022.

In The

Fourteenth Court of Appeals

NO. 14-21-00409-CV

IN THE INTEREST OF N.H., A CHILD

On Appeal from the 311th District Court

Harris County, Texas

Trial Court Cause No. 2018-36800

OPINION

May a trial court overrule the wishes of a parent and award visitation rights to

a nonparent who has no biological or legal relationship to the child? On the facts of

this case, our answer is “no.”

The trial court reached the opposite conclusion after making a finding that the

parent was unfit, but that finding has no evidentiary support. Moreover, the trial

court’s finding of unfitness is inconsistent with a separate finding that the parent

should be awarded managing conservatorship.

The trial court also found that the child would suffer significant effects if the

nonparent were denied visitation. In making that finding, the trial court appeared to

invoke the statutory standard that applies to grandparents who seek visitation of their

grandchildren. The nonparent here was not a grandparent, and there is no comparable

statute applicable to nonparents who have no biological or legal relationship to the

child. Nevertheless, we agree with the trial court that such nonparents should be

expected to meet the same demanding burden of proof as grandparents in matters

concerning visitation. In other words, to be entitled to visitation, the nonparent must

establish at a minimum that the denial of visitation would significantly impair the

child’s physical health or emotional well-being. But as we explain further below, the

nonparent here failed to carry that heavy burden.

We accordingly reverse the trial court’s order and render judgment denying

the nonparent’s petition.

BACKGROUND

The parties in this case are two women who were formerly in a dating

relationship. For ease of reference, we identify them in this opinion as the Mother

and the Ex-Girlfriend.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.