District Court, W.D. Washington October 26, 2023, 2:16-cv-00107 (City of Seattle v. Monsanto Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-10-2023

1

2

3

4

5

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

6

WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON

AT SEATTLE

7

8 CITY OF SEATTLE,

9 Plaintiff, Case No. C16-107-RAJ-MLP

10 v. ORDER

11 MONSANTO COMPANY, et al.,

12 Defendants.

13

14 I. INTRODUCTION

15 This matter is before the Court on: (1) Plaintiff City of Seattle’s (“City”) “Motion to

16 Exclude Proposed Expert Testimony by David L. Sunding” (Pl.’s Sunding Mot. (dkt. # 615)) and

17 “Motion to Strike Supplemental Report of David L. Sunding” (Pl.’s Sunding Strike Mot. (dkt.

18 # 617)); (2) the City’s “Motion to Exclude and Strike Expert Testimony by David Eaton” (Pl.’s

19 Eaton Mot. (dkt. # 619)); (3) Defendants Monsanto Company, Solutia Inc., and Pharmacia

20 LLC’s (“Defendants” or “Monsanto”) “Daubert Motion to Exclude the Expert Testimony of

21 Richard DeGrandchamp” (Defs.’ DeGrandchamp Mot. (dkt. # 628)); and (4) Defendants’

22 “Daubert Motion to Exclude Certain Opinions and Testimony of Plaintiff’s Expert Allison

23 Hiltner” (Defs.’ Hiltner Mot. (dkt. # 635)).

1 The parties have filed responses (Defs.’ Sunding Resp. (dkt. # 685); Defs.’ Sunding

2 Strike Resp. (dkt. # 687); Defs.’ Eaton Resp. (dkt. # 690); Pl.’s DeGrandchamp Resp. (dkt.

3 # 654); Pl.’s Hiltner Resp. (dkt. # 664)) and replies (Pl.’s Sunding Reply (dkt. # 702); Pl.’s

4 Sunding Strike Reply (dkt. # 704); Pl.’s Eaton Reply (dkt. # 705); Defs.’ DeGrandchamp Reply

5 (dkt. # 714); Defs.’ Hiltner Reply (dkt. # 716)) on the respective motions. The Court heard oral

6 argument from the parties on September 11, 2023. (Dkt. # 780.)

7 Having considered the parties’ submissions, oral argument, the balance of the record, and

8 the governing law: (1) the City’s Sunding Motions (dkt. ## 615, 617) are GRANTED; (2) the

9 City’s Eaton Motion (dkt. # 619) is GRANTED; (3) Defendants’ DeGrandchamp Motion (dkt.

10 # 628)) is DENIED; and (4) Defendants’ Hiltner Motion (dkt. # 635) is GRANTED in part and

11 DENIED in part, as further explained below.

12 II.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.