California Court of Appeal October 24, 2023, G061791 (The Irvine Co. v. Super. Ct.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-10-2023

Filed 9/28/23; certiified for publication 10/24/23 (order attached)

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

THE IRVINE COMPANY LLC,

Petitioner,

v. G061791

THE SUPERIOR COURT OF ORANGE (Super. Ct. No. 30-2020-01137834)

COUNTY,

OPINION

Respondent;

CHRISTINA DEMIRELLI,

Real Party in Interest.

Original proceedings; petition for a writ of mandate to challenge an order of

the Superior Court of Orange County, Donald F. Gaffney, Judge. Petition granted.

Schumann Rosenberg & Arevalo, Kim Schumann, Jeffrey P. Cunningham,

and Marlys K. Braun for Petitioner.

No appearance for Respondent.

Dordick Law Corporation, Gary A. Dordick and John M. Upton for Real

Party in Interest Christina Demirelli.

After having consumed excessive amounts of alcohol, Christina Demirelli

left a restaurant in the Fashion Island shopping center (Fashion Island) and walked

through a nearby parking structure while engaging in “displays of nonsensical

horseplay.” She found herself on an upper story of the parking structure where she seated

herself on a 43-inch tall perimeter wall, lost her balance, and fell backward out of the

structure to the ground several stories below. Demirelli sustained serious injuries.

Demirelli sued The Irvine Company, which owned the parking structure,

for premises liability, alleging the parking structure had a physical defect or dangerous

condition. The Irvine Company filed a motion for summary judgment which the trial

court denied. The Irvine Company filed a petition for writ of mandate, and we issued an

order to show cause. We now grant The Irvine Company’s petition.

In her opposition, Demirelli conceded the parking structure did not have a

physical defect or dangerous condition. In the stead of her original theory, Demirelli

asserted a new theory of liability—The Irvine Company had assumed a duty to her by

hiring a security company charged with detecting and stopping horseplay according to the

Fashion Island Code of Conduct.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.