Supreme Court of Pennsylvania November 22, 2023, 21 EAP 2022 (Zilka, D., Aplt. v. Tax Review Bd. City of Phila.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-11-2023

[J-5A-2023 and J-5B-2023] [MO: Todd, C.J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

EASTERN DISTRICT

DIANE ZILKA, : No. 20 EAP 2022

:

Appellant : Appeal from the Order of

: Commonwealth Court entered on

: January 7, 2022, at No. 1063 CD

v. : 2019 affirming the Order entered on

: June 26, 2019, in the Court of

: Common Pleas, Philadelphia

TAX REVIEW BOARD CITY OF : County, Civil Division at Nos. 02438

PHILADELPHIA, : and 02439, October Term 2018.

:

Appellee : ARGUED: March 7, 2023

DIANE ZILKA, : No. 21 EAP 2022

:

Appellant : Appeal from the Order of

: Commonwealth Court entered on

: January 7, 2022, at No. 1064 CD

v. : 2019 affirming the Order entered on

: June 26, 2019, in the Court of

: Common Pleas, Philadelphia

TAX REVIEW BOARD CITY OF : County, Civil Division at Nos. 02438

PHILADELPHIA, : and 02439, October Term 2018.

:

Appellee : ARGUED: March 7, 2023

DISSENTING OPINION

JUSTICE DOUGHERTY DECIDED: NOVEMBER 22, 2023

The Majority correctly recognizes “the crux of the dormant Commerce Clause is

that a state may not tax a transaction or incident more heavily when it crosses state lines

than when it occurs entirely within the State, nor may it impose a tax which discriminates

against interstate commerce . . . to the burden of multiple taxation[.]” Majority Opinion at

2 (internal quotation marks and citations omitted). But, in my view, failing to aggregate

state and local taxes plainly results in discrimination against interstate commerce, so I

must dissent.1

Like the Majority, I find Comptroller of Treasury v. Wynne, 575 U.S. 542 (2015) to

be “instructive on the question of aggregation.” Majority Opinion at 22. However, Wynne

is not on all fours with the present scenario and thus is persuasive, but not controlling.

The Wynne Court did not declare that state and local taxes must be aggregated for

purposes of the dormant Commerce Clause. Taxpayer culled a few passages in Wynne

to argue to the contrary.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.