Court of Appeals of Oregon August 28, 2024, A180239 (Jared v. Harmon)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-08-2024

550 August 28, 2024 No. 593

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE

STATE OF OREGON

Greg JARED,

Plaintiff-Respondent,

v.

Katie HARMON

and all occupants,

Defendant-Appellant.

Umatilla County Circuit Court

22LT13674; A180239

Jon S. Lieuallen, Judge.

Argued November 30, 2023.

Elizabeth M. Lewis argued the cause for appellant. Also

on the brief were Samara Diab, Emily Rena-Dozier, and

Legal Aid Services of Oregon.

Nick R. Blanc and The Blanc Firm, LLC filed the brief

for respondent.

Before Shorr, Presiding Judge, Mooney, Judge, and Pagán,

Judge.

MOONEY, J.

Affirmed.

Shorr, P. J., dissenting.

Cite as 334 Or App 550 (2024) 551

552 Jared v. Harmon

MOONEY, J.

In this forcible entry and detainer (FED) proceeding,

tenant appeals a judgment awarding possession to landlord

of the rented space on which tenant placed her recreational

vehicle (RV) and denying her counterclaims for injunctive

relief and damages. She seeks reversal of the judgment award-

ing landlord possession as well as the supplemental judgment

awarding him costs and attorney fees. Tenant raises three

assignments of error, asserting first that the trial court erred

in “denying tenant’s motion for involuntary dismissal,” and

second, that the trial court erred by “dismissing tenant’s hab-

itability counterclaims” based on landlord’s failure to provide

sewage disposal to the space she rented from him for her RV.

Tenant’s third assignment asserts as an alternative to her

second assignment that if the trial court did not legally err,

then it based its conclusion on the erroneous factual finding

that landlord provided tenant with sewage disposal.

Landlord responds that this appeal should be dis-

missed as moot because tenant is no longer in possession of

the leased premises and has no reasonable expectation of

returning to the leased premises. If the matter is not moot,

landlord argues that he was entitled to possession of the

leased space because (1) tenant violated her legal obligation

under ORS 90.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.