District Court, N.D. Oklahoma February 6, 2026, 4:25-cv-00433 (David A. Carpenter, special administrator of the estate of Navdeep Singh, deceased v. Mohammad By Kahla; MDS Logistics, Inc.; DMS Express Inc.; Theodore Wesley Crawford; Pacific Clay Products, Inc.; King of Freight LLC)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-02-2026
Quited States District Court
for the S2orthern District of Oklahoma
Case No. 25-cv-433-JDR-JFJ
Davip A. CARPENTER, special administrator of the estate of NAVDEEP
SINGH, deceased,
Plaintiff,
versus
MOHAMMAD By KAHLA; MDS LoaistTIics, INc.; DMS
EXPRESS INC.; THEODORE WESLEY CRAWFORD; PACIFIC CLAY
Propucts, INc.; KING OF FREIGHT LLC,
Defendants.
OPINION AND ORDER
Navdeep Singh, a truck driver, was killed when Defendant Moham-
mad Kahla struck him with his vehicle on the side of Interstate 44 in Creek
County, Oklahoma. Dkt. 2-1 at 2.' Plaintiff David Carpenter, administrator of
Mr. Singh’s estate, sued Mr. Kahla, corporate Defendants MDS Logistics
Inc., DMS Express Inc., and King of Freight LLC, and another driver, De-
fendant Theodore Crawford, in federal court. Dkt. 32 at 7. Mr. Carpenter vol-
untarily dismissed that case and filed a new action in state court, adding non-
diverse Defendant Pacific Clay Products, Inc., whose goods were being trans-
ported by Mr. Kahla at the time of the accident. Jd. at 7-8.
The parties litigated the case extensively and began discovery. Pacific
Clay moved to be dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction. Dkt. 2-18.
Months later, but while Pacific Clay’s motion was pending, MDS moved for
‘ All citations use CM/ECF pagination.
No. 25-cv-433
‘partial summary judgement, and King of Freight moved to be dismissed from
the action. Dkt. 2-77. The state court then granted Pacific Clay’s motion to
dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction without ruling on the other motions.
Dkt. 2-76. Thirty days thereafter, and within the one-year limit, MDS re-
moved the case to this Court. Dkt. 2. Mr. Carpenter now moves to remand,
arguing that the voluntary-involuntary rule precludes removal and that MDS
consented to the state court’s adjudication when it moved for partial sum-
mary judgment. Dkt. 32.
The Court concludes that removal is not barred by the voluntary-in-
voluntary rule.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit