Supreme Court 31 May 2011, US059-j (Patents (Inventions))

Also known as

International · · · 31-05-2011

U.S. Supreme Court Global-Tech Appliances, Inc. v. SEB S.A.

563 U.S. 754

2011

Justice ALITO delivered the opinion ofthe Court.

We consider whether a party who"actively induces infringement of a patent" under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) mustknow that the induced acts constitute patent infringement.

I

This case concerns a patent for aninnovative deep fryer designed by respondent SEB S.A., a French maker of homeappliances. In the late 1980's, SEB invented a "cool-touch" deepfryer, that is, a deep fryer for home use with external surfaces that remaincool during the frying process. The cool-touch deep fryer consisted of a metalfrying pot surrounded by a plastic outer housing. Attached to the housing was aring that suspended the metal pot and insulated the housing from heat byseparating it from the pot, creating air space betweenthe two components. SEB obtained a U.S. patent for its design in 1991, andsometime later, SEB started manufacturing the cool-touch fryer and selling itin this country under its well-known "T-Fal"brand. Superior to other products in the American market at the time, SEB'sfryer was a commercial success.

In 1997, Sunbeam Products, Inc., a U.S.competitor of SEB, asked petitioner PentalphaEnterprises, Ltd., to supply it with deep fryers meeting certainspecifications. Pentalpha is a Hong Kong maker ofhome appliances and a wholly owned subsidiary of petitioner Global-TechAppliances, Inc.[1]

In order to develop a deep fryer forSunbeam, Pentalpha purchased an SEB fryer in HongKong and copied all but its cosmetic features. Because the SEB fryer bought inHong Kong was made for sale in a foreign market, itbore no U.S. patent markings. After copying SEB's design, Pentalpharetained an attorney to conduct a right-to-use study, but Pentalpharefrained from telling the attorney that its design wascopied directly from SEB's.

Read the full text

This document is published by wipo.int.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.